An Indiana Judge has ruled that the state’s “Right-to-Work” law is unconstitutional, the second such blow to the legislation since its passage in 2012.
Lake County Circuit Judge George Paras decided against the state in United Steelworkers vs. Zoeller on July 17th, ruling that the law was “null and void in its entirety” and the state is “permanently enjoined” from enforcing it. The law is already before the state Supreme Court as a result of a challenge from the International Union of Operating Engineers (IUOE) Local 150. Oral arguments in that case are set to be heard on September 4th.
Following the decision, Indiana Attorney General Greg Zoeller said he would ask for a stay to prevent the decision from immediately taking effect. He also argued that the law’s fate is still truly in the hands of the state Supreme Court. From his statement:
“Strong opinions exist on both sides about involuntary union dues, but the attorney general’s office has a duty to defend the laws the legislature passes from legal challenges plaintiffs file. If a trial court finds a law unconstitutional, then the appropriate action is to stay its ruling pending the appeal.”
The IUOE Local 150 case was originally decided last fall — in favor of the union — by Lake County Superior Court Judge John Sedia. He stayed the verdict to allow it to go to the Supreme Court.
In both rulings judges agreed with the union’s argument that “Right-to-Work” violates the “particular services clause” of the state constitution. That clause states that, “No person’s particular services shall be demanded, without just compensation.” Paras agreed with this argument and wrote a strongly worded opinion that suggests this clause was written specifically to protect workers from laws like “Right-to-Work.”
Related News
- NTS Day 3: Railroad safety improvements driven by member reports
- NTS Day 3: America’s transit safer because of union member efforts
- TD NTS: STB chair and vice chair address officers, assure labor will have input
- TTD president: Labor needs to stick together to maintain progress
- TD National Training Seminar begins; officers train to confidently represent union members
- SMART-TD transit union conducts first Bus/Transit Day on the Hill
- Chairperson ensures that new bus members get what’s owed to them
- LACMTA reconstitutes in-agency police force to protect workers, riders
- Open enrollment for the SMART-TD VLTD and VLIFE plans begins for rail and bus members
- SMART-TD excited to welcome Coaster to its passenger rail/commuter family